Originally published at https://hackmd.io/@gavwood/r1jTRX2Zr by Gavin Wood.
+--------------------+| || Substrate/Edgeware || |+---------+----------+ | | +--------+---------+ | | | Client interface | | | | +--------------+ | | | Client DB | | | +--------------+ | | | +--------+---------+ | | +--------+---------+ | | | Exchange backend | | | +------------------+
Track each finalized block by subscribing with the
chain_subscribeFinalizedHeads RPC (or polling the
That will give you a stream of hashes of the most recent finalized headers.
When a new hash arrives, you can use
chain_getBlock to turn that hash into a block.
If the new block is not an immediate child of the last block you processed, make sure that you iterate over all blocks between them. Because
chain_getBlock can accept only hashes, you will need to use
chain_getBlockHash to convert numbers into hashes and in this way iterate between any two finalized blocks.
You will need to decode blocks from the basic data into useful fields.
All block data is encoded using the basic SCALE codec described in detail here. SCALE provides only the low-level underlying format however. Details of its fields and internal structure may alter between different chains and even different blocks of the same chain.
For Genesis Edgeware, the header format is a five-field structure:
struct Block: parent_hash: Hash number: Compact Number state_root: Hash extrinsics_root: Hash digest: Vec<DigestItem> extrinsics: Vec<Extrinsic>
This relies on
Hash, which is a fixed length 32-byte value or
[u8; 32] in SCALE. It also relies on
DigestItem, an enumeration type:
enum DigestItem: ChangesTrieRoot: Hash PreRuntime: ConsensusItem Consensus: ConsensusItem Seal: ConsensusItem Other: Vec<u8>struct ConsensusItem: id: [u8; 4] data: Vec<u8>
It also relies on
Extrinsic. An extrinsic is a generalisation of a transaction and other (unsigned) external information. It is a highly extensible type which doesn’t have a fixed format per se. To ensure future format compatibility, metadata concerning the extrinsic format is provided through an RPC
The metadata itself is provided encoded in SCALE. Its format is:
struct Metadata: magic: u32 version: u8 modules: Vec<Module>struct Module: name: String prefix: String storage: Option Vec<Storage> calls: Option Vec<Call> events: Option Vec<Event> constants: Vec<Constant>enum StorageHasher: Blake2_128 Blake2_256 Twox128 Twox256 Twox64Concatstruct Constant: name: String type: Type value: Vec<u8> documentation: Vec<String>struct Storage: name: String modifier: StorageModifier type: StorageType default: Vec<u8> documentation: Vec<String>enum StorageModifier: Optional Defaultenum StorageType: Plain: Type Map: StorageMapType DoubleMap: StorageDoubleMapTypestruct StorageMapType: hasher: StorageHasher key: Type value: Type iterable: boolstruct StorageDoubleMapType: hasher: StorageHasher first_key: Type second_key: Type value: Type iterable: boolstruct Call: name: String arguments: Vec<CallArg> documentation: Vec<String>struct CallArg: name: String type: Typestruct Event: name: String arguments: Vec<Type> documentation: Vec<String>
Type is just a
String, but the contents of the string are to be interpreted as the name of a type.
Substrate chains (specifically Substrate chains built using the SRML) such as Edgeware are composed of various modules. Each module can be imagined a little bit like a smart contract, with various kinds of transactions (or, in Substrate terms, extrinsics), data items that persist between transactions and blocks, events and constant parameters. The metadata encodes all of these things, allowing your client code to both create particular transactions or interpret what has happened on the chain, even between different Substrate blockchains or over many different upgrades or forks of the same chain.
There are two modules an exchange needs to be aware of: Balances and Indices. Balances allows you to send and receive funds between different accounts. Indices allows you to interpret user addresses.
In Edgeware (and most Substrate chains), user accounts are identified by a 32-byte (256-bit) AccountId. This is simply the public key for the x25519 cryptography used by Substrate.
However, to keep the addresses small, we index every account with a non-zero balance on Edgeware and use just this index to identify the account. This index is much smaller than the 32-byte AccountId, and can usually be encoded in just a couple of bytes.
Where Bitcoin has the Check58 address format and Ethereum used the
0x... hex format, Edgeware (and Substrate) use the SS58 address format. This is a broad “meta-format” designed to handle many different cryptographies and chains. It has much in common with Bitcoin’s Check58 format such as a version prefix, a hash-based checksum suffix and base-58 encoding. Further information on it can be found here [TODO]. Of the many supported “version codes”, only one particular family of subformats is especially important for Edgeware support in exchanges.
The SS58 format is a base-58 encoding (using the same alphabet as Bitcoin) of a version prefix (which is one byte and always
0x07 for Edgeware) followed by one or more payload bytes and ending with one or more checksum bytes:
0x00 <payload bytes> <checksum bytes>
An address does not have a fixed length. Depending on the length, the payload may have a different meaning and there could be a different ratio of payload to checksum bytes. Here is a table to consult to determine how to interpret an address of a particular size:
NOTE: This table contains only the most common combinations; SS58 includes several more uncommon ones. For maximum compatibility then implement according to the full SS58 specification.Welcome/
Once decoded into the fields, then the version should be checked to be
0x00. The checksum should then be verified as being equivalent to the beginning of the Blake2-256 hash of the SS58 data, not including the checksum itself. If the checksum is one byte, then only the first byte of the hash is checked. If it is two bytes, then the first two bytes of the hash are checked.
Finally, in the case of an indexed address, the index should be decoded into a 32-byte account identifier. This can be done by inspecting the storage of the Indices module.
Looking up an index is a bit fiddly, since it involves looking up some storage and decoding and interpreting it.
The specific storage item that we care about is
EnumSet in the
Indices module. Inspecting the storage is done through the
state_getStorage RPC, to which a key must be supplied. The key encodes the entire “query”. In general, the metadata should be consulted on how to generate the key. To do this, we first find the
Module whose name is
Indices, then find the entry in that module’s
storage field of the
Storage item with the name
EnumSet. This item contains all the information we need to construct and interpret the query.
For Edgeware, we find that the item has a
Map whose associate value is a
T::AccountIndex (equivalent to a
u32 for Edgeware ) and whose
This means that if our index, encoded by SCALE as a
<INDEX>, then our storage key is determined through the Blake2 256 hash of the string
Indices EnumSet<INDEX>. In fact, accounts are stored in batches of 64, so to look up a particular index, we don’t query by the account index but rather the index of its batch. This just means we first need to divide the index by 64 before encoding.
This will return a SCALE-encoded
T::AccountId may be defined in SCALE as
[u8; 32] or a 32-byte fixed quantity) of up the batch that contains the account we are interested in. To get the
AccountId item, just take the
index % 64th item from the vector. If that item doesn’t exist (or you get an empty storage item), then the account index is invalid.
Otherwise, you have your account ID and it can be displayed to the user along with its identicon and balance.
In Edgeware, account balances can be looked up within the
Balances module using the metadata in a manner not dissimilar to looking up an account index. In this case, we need to query the
FreeBalance item in storage. Here, the
StorageMapType is similar, except that the
key is of type
T::AccountId (the 32-byte quantity) and the
BalanceOf<T>, which for the purposes of Edgeware is a
u128 (128-bit value). The hash function is the same Blake2 256, so the full storage key would be given by the Blake2 256 hash of the string
Balances FreeBalance<ID> where
<ID> is the 32-byte
FreeBalance gives the total balance controlled by that account, but does not account for temporarily locked portions of balance, such as those locked for staking, voting or vesting. This information can be queried from the chain, but it is outside the scope of this document.
The balance encodes the EDGtoken with 18 decimal places. To get the actual number of EDGs, you need to divide the 128-bit balance by 1E18 (10**18). For completeness, The exact denominations of the Edgeware currency are:
To transfer a balance, a transaction must be constructed and sent. In constructing a transaction, there are two key parts: the general part of the transaction and the module-specific
function part of the transaction with the latter generally needing information from the chain’s metadata must generally.
In general, Edgeware’s transactions are encoded as signed
Extrinsics in SCALE. To facilitate forward compatibility, extrinsics are double-encoded, so the initial encoding is passed back into SCALE (as a
Vec<u8>) and the output of that is used. This has the effect of adding a small length prefix onto it allowing systems that cannot interpret the transaction data itself to still be able to pass them around as opaque packets of data.
The SCALE format is given by
struct Extrinsic: tx: Option TransactionInfo function: Functionstruct TransactionInfo: sender: Address sig: [u8; 64] era: Era nonce: Compact Nonce tip: Compact Balancestruct TransactionPayload: function: Function era: Era nonce: Nonce tip: Balance checkpoint_hash: Hash
For a transaction, the optional
tx is always used. The
Address type is a specially encoded SCALE type, allowing an account to be presented either as an account index or as a 32-byte account ID, whichever is more convenient. The format is described here in the SCALE [TODO]. Assuming you wish to present a 32-byte account ID, then it can be expressed as an
Address merely by prefixing the
sig field must contain a 25519-family signature of the SCALE-encoded
SigPayload. The key used to sign the payload must correspond to the
sender account. Schnorr/Ristretto 25519 (“sr25519”) is the recommended signing format to use.
Era is a one or two byte item, again with a special SCALE encoding format and it encodes the period (as a range of blocks) for which this transaction should be considered valid. It is an important safeguard against certain transaction replay attacks and should generally be used, however a simple exchange implementation that has no plans to reuse accounts after they become empty should be able to safely ignore it. To ignore it and make the transaction “immortal”, use an encoded
Era of just one byte:
The nonce is the number of transactions send so far by the sender account, much like in Ethereum. It is of type
Nonce, logically equivalent to a
u64. To get the correct value, the appropriate storage item must be queried, much like when querying an account’s balance. In this case, it is the
AccountNonce item; thus the storage key required is the Blake2 256 hash of the string
System AccountNonce<ID> where
<ID> is the 32-byte
AccountId. It will return a
Nonce which may be decoded and used here.
NOTE: The nonce retrieved from storage does not take into account pending transactions. If you are sending more than one transaction from a single account at a time, then you will need to increment and track this value manually.
tip is a
Balance (logically equivalent to the
u128 type in SCALE), which denotes some additional fees paid to the block author for prioritized inclusion at busy times. It will typically be zero.
checkpoint_hash is the hash of the “checkpoint block”, which is to say the first block of the era specified by the
era field. If just making the transaction “immortal”, then the genesis hash of the blockchain should be used. This can be determined through the RPC
function is a
Function type (sometimes known as a
Proposal in certain contexts) which describes what action shall be dispatched. It must be constructed according to metadata. In this case, we want our transaction to effect the
transfer function in the
Balances module, to transfer a balance from one account to another. It is important to check the index of the Balances module itself in the list of modules. In this case, it is the 6th item, or index 5. It is also necessary to inspect the
calls field of the Balances
Module in the metadata, and determine what index in the list of calls the transfer function is. As it happens, it is first in the list, and thus has an index of 0.
Finally, we need to know what parameters to this function are expected in order to construct the rest of the transaction. This is provided in the
Call item of the metadata that we just located. Two parameters are expected:
dest with a type of
<T::Lookup as StaticLookup>::Source (aka
value with a type of
function in this case (i.e. specifically and only for the Balance transfer transaction on Edgeware as of right now) would be the struct:
struct BalanceTransferFunction: module_index: u8 call_index: u8 dest: Address value: Compact Balance
dest is similar to
sender and may be provided as either an account index or a 32-byte account ID, whichever is more convenient. If providing as an account ID, then it can be formed into an address simply by prefixing the byte
0xff to it.
The amount to be transferred (not including any fees payable to the system) is given by
value, and must be a SCALE compact-encoded number.
Once a transaction has been crafted, you will need to submit it for inclusion in the chain and eventually want to verify that it has indeed been included.
This can be done in two ways: one is to use the simple RPC
author_submitExtrinsic, which will return the transaction’s hash. Once submitted, you can keep checking transactions in finalized blocks manually (since you are tracking the finalized heads anyway) until you see the transaction you submitted, at which point you know it is in the chain.
The other way is to use the pub/sub RPC
author_submitAndWatchExtrinsic. Again, you provide the SCALE-encoded transaction, but here you receive a subscription ID. You will be notified over the RPC as the transaction gets validated, broadcast and included in the chain with separate messages that are pushed.
This concludes the article. Here you should have a good idea of how to interact with a Substrate/Edgeware node in order to track the finalized chain head, to decode SS58 addresses, check account information like balances & nonces and to construct, submit and track transactions. You’ve also learnt a little about the SCALE codec, the Substrate metadata system and how to build future-proof and generic Substrate-based systems.